Editor guide - overview

Editor guide - overview page

This guide walks editors through the editorial workflow in Janeway, from a new submission to publication. Each stage below links to a dedicated page with step-by-step instructions.

The workflow at a glance

The workflow at a glance section

Every article moves through the same core stages, though there are additional, optional and/or alternative stages.

  1. Submission. New articles start out unassigned. An editor assigns an editor or section editor to the article, then decides whether to move it to review, accept it outright, or decline it.
  2. Review. Reviewers assess the manuscript. Editors can run multiple review rounds, request revisions, and share reviews with authors and reviewers.
  3. Copyediting. A copyeditor prepares the accepted manuscript for typesetting. Authors can review the copyedited manuscript before it moves on.
  4. Typesetting. Manuscript files are converted into publishable galleys (PDF, HTML, and/or JATS XML) and then proofread.
  5. Pre-publication. Final checks confirm the metadata, issue assignment, DOI, galley selection, publication date, and article image before the article goes live.
  6. Published. The article is available to readers.

Not every article follows this path exactly. See Workflow variations for the most common branches.

Workflow variations

Workflow variations section
  • Skip review. At the submission stage, editors can accept an article outright (for example, editorials) and send it straight to copyediting, bypassing peer review.
  • Decline at any stage. Articles can be declined at submission or after a review round. Declining removes the article from the workflow and notifies the author.
  • Multiple review rounds. After an author submits requested revisions, editors can open a new review round instead of moving straight to a decision.
  • Draft decisions. If your journal enables this option, section editors draft a decision (accept, minor revisions, major revisions, conditional accept, or decline) for an editor to review and approve, rather than deciding directly.
  • Typesetting method. Editors can upload galleys manually, generate HTML galleys from a DOCX or RTF file using the Pandoc plugin, or assign the work to an external typesetter. A journal can use more than one method. Typesetting can also be skipped if you wish to only publish the format an article was submitted in.
  • Proofing. Editors can invite authors, editors, or dedicated proofreaders to check galleys before publication, and send flagged issues back to the typesetter for correction.

There are other variations available; removing copyediting, only using Janeway to display published articles rather than processing them in the system, working with repositories etc. For more information on this, contact the Janeway developer team or your system administrator.

Table of contents

Table of contents section